Join our weekly Wednesday workshops to tackle your most pressing email deliverability hurdles!

Effectiveness of Pre-Send Testing Tools in Predicting Deliverability Issues

March 17, 2025
minutes
Effectiveness of Pre-Send Testing Tools in Predicting Deliverability Issues

Many email campaigns fail before they even reach the inbox due to email deliverability issues. ISPs evaluate every message, deciding whether it belongs in the inbox, or spam folder, or should be blocked entirely. Without insight into this process, marketers are often left guessing why their emails aren’t getting through.

Pre-send testing tools identify potential problems before an email is sent. By analyzing spam triggers, authentication records, and inbox placement, these tools help businesses fix deliverability issues in advance rather than discovering them after engagement rates drop.

But how accurate are these tests? Can they truly prevent emails from being flagged or blocked? This article explores how pre-send testing works, what it can and can’t predict, and how to integrate it into your strategy to improve email deliverability and campaign success.

Why Is Email Deliverability the Foundation of Successful Campaigns?

No matter how compelling your email content is, it means nothing if your messages never reach the inbox. Email deliverability refers to the ability of an email to successfully land in a recipient’s inbox rather than being filtered into spam or blocked entirely. It’s the foundation of every successful email marketing campaign—without it, open rates drop, engagement plummets and potential revenue is lost.

A strong email deliverability strategy ensures that marketing efforts are not wasted. Factors like sender reputation, authentication protocols, and spam filter triggers all play a role in whether an email reaches its intended destination. Understanding these elements is key to maintaining inbox placement and maximizing the impact of email marketing.

The Cost of Poor Deliverability

When emails fail to reach inboxes, businesses lose engagement and money. Poor email deliverability can mean fewer conversions, declining customer trust, and wasted marketing spending.

  • Financial Loss: Email marketing ROI depends on high inbox placement. If a large portion of emails never reach recipients, that’s lost potential revenue.
  • Damage to Brand Reputation: Being flagged as spam can lead to long-term consequences, making it harder to regain trust with ISPs and subscribers.
  • Lower Engagement Rates: When emails don’t reach the inbox, open and click-through rates drop, affecting overall campaign performance.

Deliverability isn't just a technical concern for businesses that rely on email marketing for customer acquisition, retention, and sales—it directly impacts profitability.

Connecting Pre-Send Testing to Deliverability Success

Rather than waiting for deliverability issues to affect campaigns, pre-send testing tools offer a proactive approach. These tools allow marketers to analyze emails before they’re sent, identifying potential red flags that could cause messages to be blocked or filtered into spam.

Pre-send testing tools provide critical insights that help improve email success by checking for authentication failures, spam trigger words, and inbox placement risks. Instead of sending blindly and hoping for the best, marketers can take control of their email deliverability, ensuring messages reach the right audience at the right time.

Understanding the Barriers to Inbox Success

Imagine running a race where obstacles appear out of nowhere—potholes in the track, hurdles that slow you down, and even detours that send you in the wrong direction. No matter how fast you run, these hidden roadblocks make it nearly impossible to reach the finish line. Email deliverability issues work the same way. You might craft the perfect email, but if unseen factors are working against you, your message may never reach its intended destination.

Many marketers focus on email design, messaging, and timing but overlook the invisible obstacles determining whether an email lands in the inbox. From authentication failures to poor content optimization, these unseen deliverability challenges can quietly derail even the most well-planned campaigns.

Hidden Deliverability Factors

Several behind-the-scenes issues can cause emails to be blocked, filtered into spam, or completely ignored:

  • Poor Email Content Optimization
    Spam filters analyze subject lines, body text, and formatting. Overuse of trigger words, excessive images, or unbalanced text-to-image ratios can lead to emails being flagged as spam.

  • Insufficient Authentication Protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)
    Email providers verify senders using authentication protocols. Without properly configured SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records, your emails may look suspicious, leading ISPs to block or filter them.

  • Neglected Sender Reputation and List Hygiene
    ISPs track engagement levels, complaint rates, and bounce rates to determine whether to trust your emails. A poor sender reputation—caused by sending emails to unengaged or outdated contacts—can lower deliverability over time.

When Authentication Goes Wrong

A company launches a promotional email campaign, expecting high engagement, but sees unusually low open rates. After investigating, they realized that their DKIM signatures were not properly configured, causing major ISPs to reject their emails or classify them as suspicious. Without proper authentication, even well-designed emails can fail to reach subscribers—making email deliverability a technical challenge as much as a marketing one.

Exploring How Pre-Send Testing Tools Work

Pre-send testing tools act as a preventative checkpoint, allowing marketers to detect and fix issues before emails are sent. Rather than waiting for engagement metrics to reveal problems after the fact, these tools provide real-time feedback on potential deliverability risks, helping businesses improve inbox placement and avoid spam filters.

Authentication Check: Verifying SPF, DKIM, and DMARC for Domain Safety

Email authentication protocols play a critical role in email deliverability by proving that messages come from a legitimate sender. Pre-send testing tools analyze SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records, ensuring they are properly configured to prevent spoofing and phishing attacks.

For example, if an SPF record isn’t aligned with an email provider, ISPs might flag the email as suspicious—even if the sender is legitimate. A misconfigured DKIM signature can have the same effect, reducing the likelihood of inbox placement. Pre-send testing tools detect these inconsistencies before an email is sent, allowing marketers to fix authentication failures in advance.

Reputation Analysis: Predicting Inbox Placement Success

Beyond authentication, the sender reputation is key in determining whether an email is delivered or blocked. ISPs track engagement levels, spam complaints, and blacklist status to gauge whether a sender is trustworthy. Pre-send testing tools assess these elements, giving marketers a deliverability score predicting whether their emails will land in the inbox or face rejection.

If a domain has been flagged on a blacklist, pre-send testing tools alert senders before emails are deployed—giving them the opportunity to address reputation issues before deliverability is affected.

Content Testing for Spam Triggers

Even with a strong sender reputation and proper authentication, an email can still be filtered into spam due to its content. Pre-send testing tools analyze subject lines, body text, and formatting to detect elements that commonly trigger spam filters.

For instance, an email loaded with aggressive sales language, misleading formatting, or too many images might score poorly in spam filter testing. Instead of waiting for poor engagement metrics to highlight the issue, pre-send testing tools provide insights upfront, allowing marketers to refine content and improve inbox placement.

Choosing the Right Pre-Send Testing Tool

Different tools specialize in various aspects of email deliverability testing. Some focus heavily on authentication checks, while others provide deeper insights into spam filter behavior or inbox placement predictions.

For example, a tool designed for inbox placement testing can show whether emails are likely to land in the primary inbox, promotions tab, or spam folder across different ISPs. Meanwhile, another tool may prioritize content analysis, identifying words and formatting patterns that reduce deliverability. Marketers need to evaluate their email deliverability challenges before selecting the right pre-send testing tool to integrate into their strategy.

By strategically using pre-send testing, businesses reduce the risk of sending emails that never reach their audience, ensuring that each campaign has the best chance of success.

Common Mistakes Marketers Overlook in Email Deliverability

Many email deliverability issues are preventable, yet marketers overlook small but critical factors impacting inbox placement. These mistakes might seem insignificant at first, but they can quickly add up, causing emails to land in spam folders or get blocked entirely. Understanding these common pitfalls is the first step toward ensuring emails reach their intended audience.

Sending Emails from Free Domains or Unverified Addresses

Using generic email addresses (like @gmail.com or @yahoo.com) for marketing emails can damage credibility and reduce inbox placement. ISPs are more likely to filter messages from free domains, assuming they are spam or phishing attempts.

Quick Fix: Always send emails from a verified domain with proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication. This signals to ISPs that your messages are legitimate.

Overloading Content with Trigger Words or Irrelevant Images

Spam filters analyze email content for phrases commonly associated with scams, excessive use of images, or unbalanced formatting. Emails that overuse aggressive sales language or have too little text compared to images can be flagged as spam.

Quick Fix: Avoid overly promotional phrasing like “100% free” or “limited-time offer” in subject lines and body text. Keep a healthy balance between text and images to ensure email content remains credible.

Neglecting to Warm Up New IPs or Domains

Sending large emails from a brand-new IP or domain without building a sending reputation can lead to immediate deliverability issues. ISPs view sudden spikes in email volume as suspicious, often blocking or throttling delivery.

Quick Fix: Start by sending a small number of emails and gradually increase volume over several weeks. Engaging with highly active subscribers first can help establish a positive reputation with ISPs.

Failing to Clean Subscriber Lists of Inactive Contacts

Continuously sending emails to outdated or unresponsive addresses harms the sender reputation. High bounce rates and low engagement levels signal to ISPs that emails may not be relevant, increasing the chances of being filtered into spam.

Quick Fix: Regularly clean your list by removing inactive subscribers or sending re-engagement campaigns before permanently unsubscribing them. A well-maintained list improves deliverability and boosts engagement.

Skipping Pre-Send Tests for Authentication and Content Evaluation

Many marketers assume that if their emails are well-designed and sent from a verified domain, they will land in the inbox. However, skipping pre-send testing leaves room for unnoticed authentication failures, spam triggers, or formatting issues that reduce email deliverability.

Quick Fix: Always run a pre-send test to check for authentication alignment (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), spam filter risks, and inbox placement predictions. Catching potential issues before hitting send ensures a higher chance of reaching the inbox.

By addressing these common mistakes, marketers increase email deliverability rates, improve engagement, and maintain a strong sender reputation—all of which contribute to long-term email marketing success.

Understanding Metrics That Measure Deliverability Success

Improving email deliverability isn’t just about avoiding spam filters—it’s about tracking performance over time and making data-driven adjustments. Without clear visibility into key metrics, marketers may not realize when email deliverability issues are affecting their campaigns. Measuring success requires monitoring inbox placement, bounce rates, and spam complaints while using tracking tools to diagnose and fix issues before they escalate.

Key Metrics Overview

Several critical indicators determine whether emails are successfully reaching inboxes and engaging recipients:

  • Inbox Placement Rate (IPR) Measures the percentage of emails that land in inboxes rather than being spammed or blocked. A high IPR signals a good sender reputation and optimized deliverability.
  • Bounce Rate: Tracks emails that couldn’t be delivered due to invalid addresses (hard bounces) or temporary issues like full inboxes (soft bounces). High bounce rates indicate poor list hygiene or authentication problems.
  • Spam Complaint Rate: This shows how often recipients mark emails as spam. Even a small percentage of spam complaints can severely damage sender reputation, making it harder for future emails to reach inboxes.

By consistently monitoring these metrics, marketers can identify and correct deliverability issues before they impact email performance.

Tools for Tracking Metrics

While pre-send testing tools help prevent deliverability failures before emails are sent, tracking tools provide insights into real-world performance after sending. Some widely used platforms for monitoring email deliverability include:

  • Google Postmaster Tools: Provides reputation insights, spam complaint data, and inbox placement reports for Gmail users.
  • GlockApps: Simulates inbox placement and spam filter testing across various email providers.
  • SenderScore by Validity: Evaluates sender reputation by analyzing email engagement and blacklist status.

Using these tools alongside pre-send testing ensures a comprehensive deliverability strategy, combining predictive insights with real-world data.

Analyzing and Acting on Poor Bounce Rates

A SaaS company noticed a sharp increase in bounce rates after launching a re-engagement campaign. Using Google Postmaster Tools, they discovered that many of their emails were bouncing due to invalid addresses—likely from outdated subscriber data.

To fix the issue, they:

  1. Remove hard-bounced addresses to improve list hygiene.
  2. Implement a double opt-in process to ensure new subscribers provide valid emails.
  3. Use a pre-send testing tool to check future email lists for potential deliverability risks.

As a result, their bounce rate decreases, the sender reputation improves, and future campaigns reach more inboxes, leading to higher engagement.

Businesses can maintain high inbox placement rates and stronger email marketing performance by consistently monitoring these deliverability metrics and leveraging pre-send testing alongside real-world tracking tools.

6 Steps to Start Improving Deliverability Today

Email deliverability success doesn’t happen by chance—it requires proactive testing, authentication, and continuous monitoring. By implementing these key steps, businesses can significantly improve inbox placement, boost engagement, and reduce the risk of email deliverability issues.

1. Authenticate Sender Domains with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC

ISPs use authentication protocols to verify whether an email is legitimate. Without proper setup, emails may be rejected or filtered into spam.

SPF authorizes specific mail servers, DKIM prevents message tampering, and DMARC instructs ISPs on how to handle unauthenticated emails. Ensuring these records are correctly configured is essential for inbox placement.

2. Test Emails Before Sending

Skipping pre-send testing is like sending emails blindly. Pre-send tools detect spam triggers, authentication failures, and inbox placement risks before emails are sent.

Testing before launch helps catch issues early, allowing marketers to adjust content, authentication, and sending practices before deliverability suffers.

3. Monitor Domain Reputation and Blacklist Status

A damaged sender reputation makes ISPs more likely to filter emails into spam. Blacklist placement, high spam complaints, and low engagement signal that emails aren’t trustworthy.

Regularly monitoring Google Postmaster Tools and reputation tracking platforms helps businesses catch and resolve reputation issues before they escalate.

4. Use Double Opt-Ins to Keep Lists Engaged

Sending emails to unverified or inactive subscribers lowers engagement and increases spam complaints. A disengaged list damages deliverability over time.

Using double opt-in ensures that only interested recipients receive emails, improving open rates and reducing the risk of spam complaints.

5. Make Unsubscribing Easy

If subscribers can’t find the unsubscribe button, they mark emails as spam instead—which directly hurts sender reputation.

A clear, one-click unsubscribe process keeps email lists clean and engaged while ensuring compliance with privacy regulations like GDPR and CAN-SPAM.

6. Analyze Results and Adjust

Tracking open rates, bounce rates, and spam complaints provides insight into what’s working and what’s hurting deliverability.

Regular analysis helps businesses refine email frequency, authentication settings, and content strategies, ensuring consistent inbox placement and engagement.

By following these steps, marketers can proactively prevent email deliverability issues, protect the sender reputation, and improve campaign performance.

Taking Control of Email Deliverability

Email marketing success depends on more than great content—it starts with ensuring emails actually reach inboxes. Many email deliverability issues go unnoticed until open rates drop, spam complaints increase, or engagement declines. Pre-send testing tools provide a proactive solution, helping marketers identify authentication failures, spam triggers, and inbox placement risks before emails are sent.

Businesses can significantly increase inbox placement and maintain a strong sender reputation by integrating pre-send testing into your email workflow, monitoring key deliverability metrics, and addressing common mistakes like poor authentication and list hygiene. Rather than guessing whether emails will be delivered, marketers can make data-driven decisions that optimize deliverability, improve engagement, and drive better campaign performance.

The key to long-term success? Consistency. Regular testing, authentication checks, and reputation monitoring ensure that email campaigns stay effective over time. Instead of reacting to deliverability problems after they happen, marketers who take a proactive approach gain the advantage of reaching their audience with every send.

Subscribe to our newsletter
Arrow
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Senders' Videos

Senders Case Studies
SUSO Digital
Industry - Marketing & SEO
Project length - 2 years
Key result - Market growth, funnel saturation
GROWRK
Industry - Information Technology & Services
Project length - Ongoing
Key result - New market penetration
Pangea.io
Industry - Fintech
Project length - Ongoing
Key result - Safely scaled email outbound, moved off of Google, improved processes 

Founded by chef David Chang, Momofuku is a renowned culinary brand with a nation-wide presence, including restaurants and an online store with delicious goods. They ran into an issue with their email sending – high bounce rates and blocked sending.

With hundreds of thousands of people on their email lists eager to stay informed, and an impeccable reputation to uphold, Momofuku wanted to nip this problem in the bud quickly.

  • Momofuku reached out to Senders to run a diagnostic test on their sending infrastructure and find the root cause
  • Senders deliverability experts discovered an issue with their DMARC, which was preventing emails from being sent, as their WordPress wasn't aligned with their SPF
  • Senders provided the most effective solution helping Momofuku restore safe sending, and suggested next steps to ensure everything keeps running smoothly on their end
  • The client reported that Senders helped identify the problem and got them back on track 

Up for coffee with a health kick, sans the jitters? Try Everyday Dose – a brand on a mission to provide coffee lovers with a healthy alternative packed with all kinds of goodies. The Founder, Jack Savage, learned through personal experience that we needed an option that doesn’t lead to a slew of possible side-effects. That’s how this mushroom-based blend with nootropics and collagen protein came to be, helping boost focus, energy, and reduce stress in one go.

The Everyday Dose team prides itself on excellent customer support, in addition to their delicious set of products. So when they spotted DNS propagation issues setting up their customer experience platform, they reached out to Senders to find the best way to sort it out.

  • Senders deliverability experts confirmed the problem the team at Everyday Dose initially diagnosed
  • To enable healthy DNS propagation, the Senders team helped clean their DNS registrar of old DNS records that were causing issues with propagation
  • The client reported they were now able to set up their DNS correctly, enabling them to run their platform smoothly

Myrina.ai stands out as a trailblazer in empowering women entrepreneurs through technology and a supportive community.

Myrina.ai offers a cutting-edge range of AI-powered SaaS marketing and sales tools that cater specifically to female entrepreneurs and women-led businesses. Myrina.ai enables users to automate marketing and sales, while helping them scale their authentic selves while saving time and boosting conversions. Their Myrina’s Army community fosters a supportive platform that champions female entrepreneurs and their values, empowering them to conquer barriers and achieve their business goals. The company's dedication to providing not only top-notch technological solutions but also a platform for networking and mentorship underscores their commitment to fostering success among women in the entrepreneurial space.

Naturally, they wanted to make sure their email sending infrastructure was set up correctly to protect their reputation and successfully reach their recipients. Our deliverability team worked with the client’s team on:

  • Aligning the client’s three domains with Amazon to make sure they are compatible and optimized in order to integrate with Amazon’s system.
  • Setting up a proper DMARC policy to protect their domains against unauthorized use and phishing scams.
  • Enhancing email deliverability as well as security, so that each email sent from these domains can be properly authenticated and more likely to land in the right inbox.
  • As a result, the client can protect the reputation of their business and domains, while safely sending out their email campaigns.

Sometimes the sheer number of options of any product can be daunting – how on earth do you pick the right one? This is especially true with supplements, as we can find them just about anywhere, but we can rarely understand a third of the ingredients listed. Unlike most, Physician’s Choice provides supplements with pure, potent ingredients that work. No fillers or “proprietary” blends with unidentified ingredients. They do the research, so you don’t have to.

Integrity and transparency are part of their core values, so when their team ran into sending issues, they were referred to Senders.

  • The client’s team spotted issues with DMARC failures in Google Postmaster
  • The Senders deliverability team worked with the client to update the DMARC configuration to enable report collection
  • The client is now able to obtain detailed reports to diagnose the exact causes of the failures and prevent them in the future with proper DMARC setup
Looking for tenant improvements in DFW? Discover how we can help here.
All Case Studies